Skip to main content

Gilgit-Baltistan's Transition

BY SAJJAD AHMAD - Orignally Published on Dawn News.

GILTI-BALTISTAN goes to polls tomorrow to elect members to its legislative assembly. The first successful and democratic transition from one government to the other in the post-2009 set-up makes the election particularly important.

Election fever is running high in the region. Gilgit-Baltistan is flooded with party flags, which in the run-up to the polls have been frequent rallies and public gatherings. In fact, the political ‘great debates’ in Hunza and Skardu - titled “Why should we vote for you?’ - have brought rival contestants to one table to share their election manifestos in front of voters. The videos of these debates were broadcast through local cable networks to make them accessible to a larger audience. Such democratic steps have rarely been witnessed elseqhere in Pakistan.

Visit by opposing contestants to each others’ offices in many contestants to each others’ offices in many constituencies and disciplined gatherings also reflect public maturity. The high literacy rate of GB can be construed as one of the factors behind such a political culture. Despite remaining far from the national electoral process, the region has proved its zeal for democracy.

The previous PPP government did not quite meet the aspirations of the people. Charges of corruption - particularly in the education department - and nepotism have affected the party’s reputation locally. While the PML-N is expected to gain as it heads the government in the centre, new political entrants in the region, such as Pakistan Tehreek-i-Insaf (PTI) and Majlis Wadatul Muslimeen (MWM), are set to take advantage of the PPP’s poor performance. Both parties have the potential not only to damage the vote bank of other candidates but also to win a few seats. The reason for MWM’s popularity is the large Shia population residing in GB. Apart from demographics, the MWM has made efforts to foster religious harmony between Shia and Sunni communities, which has improved its graph.

PTI is con testing elections in GB for the first time. The party has vowed to bring development and give rights to the people through local bodies. Criticism of the PML-N’s policies and allegations of pre-poll rigging have remained the focus of PTI’s campaign in the region. The N-League, on its part, has put forward the agenda of GB’s infrastructure development. The region lacks modern infrastructure and facilities and heavily relies on the federal budget. Due to non-representation in the national legislature, GB is also not part of the NFC Award, which provides financial allocations to the provinces. Annual funds allocated to GB by Islamabad are insufficient for such a vast mountainous terrain.

The PPP has again pledged to improve the living nconditions of the common people, but the party’s lackluster performance in the previous term will weigh heavily against it. Nationalist leader Baba Jan has shown promise in Hunza. The mishandling of his case by the state has increased support for the leader.

Despite all the activity in the run-up to the polls, real empowerment of this little developed region remains elusive. When the Gilgit-baltistan Empowerment and Self-Governance Order was announced in 2009, the GB Council was created along the pattern of the AJK Council. This body has come under considerable criticism by local leaders. The GB council is a powerful unelected body headed by the prime minister.

Though the presidential order of 2009 has transferred some decision-making powers to locally elected members and increased legislative subjects of the assembly, important subject such as administration and revenue remain in the council’s domain. The assembly can only pass the budget but control over financial matters and revenue comes under the council’s authority. This Islamabad is accused of keeping tight control over GB’s resources and the package is termed cosmetic.

Since important administrative and financial decisions rest with the council, the elections to the legislative assembly will provide only restricted opportunities to the locals to determine their fate. The primary demand of the population is self-rule and autonomy. The freedom struggle of the people of GB was diredcted at liberating the region from Kashmir and associating it with Pakistan. Yet in the years after independence, GB was still associated with its former master and denied its political rights.

Ironically, in 1974 through the Interim Constitution Act, government institutions were established in Azad Jammu and Kashmir. This act provided for self-rule and a constitution for AJK. The region is relatively independent in its decision-making and only defence, foreign relations and currency are maintained by Pakistan. GB, however, is still deprived of this right.

The real transfer of power to GB from Islamabad - as in the case of AJK - is one of the ways to address the question of self-rule. Unless the assembly and the elected members are given the power to take decisions about their region, elections would fail to truly empower GB.

The writer is a senior research fellow at Karachi University.


Popular posts from this blog

Gilgit-Baltistan – A Historical Narrative

BySyed Shamsuddin

Perceptibly, there abound divergent narratives and counter narratives wittingly or unwittingly churned out as to status of Gilgit-Baltistan which more often than not, have no bearing on and are sadly devoid of any substance when put in the correct historical perspective. In order to get the best and clearest possible picture, it becomes imperative to have a full view of and delve deeper into its background with a view to irrefutably place facts connected with the matter in the correct historical order by separating what is called the wheat from the chaff for the information of the readers as follows:
Strictly speaking, the region fell on turbulent times and troublous waters during the second half of the nineteenth century which may, with profit, be called the period of uncertainty and the gloomiest transitional phase in Gilgit-Baltistan’s context. Synoptically, region consisted of and apportioned into a dozen tiny kingdoms each ruled by despotic, independent rulers f…

Foiling India’s Inimical Designs

BySyed Shamsuddin A very interesting summation, aptly encompassing has been going on in Gilgit-Baltistan (GB) overtime in socio-political context, was published in a regional Urdu daily the other day. The learned writer offered a peep into the brief historical background of the region dating to the post-independence period, and referred precisely to what happened preceding the liberation of Gilgit-Baltistan. Beginning with briefly recording of the facts about how the British colonizers packed off by giving back the territory of Gilgit, in August 1947, to the Dogra occupiers, quite intriguingly with the condition that the latter would retain Major William Brown – a British military officer – to assign him the command of Gilgit Scouts. The move was ostensibly aimed at checking effectively and blocking Russo-China contacts, as well as to preclude Gilgit region from the impact of communists inroads into this land.
After the successful revolution of 1st November 1947, Gilgit emerged as a…

Eulogizing The Protectors of Culture and Tradition

BySyed Shamsuddin QUITE PROPITIOUSLY, a flurry of activities is getting underway in the context of revival of Shina language in its original form and diction. This is in addition to the marked efforts afoot to build a consensus among the literary circles formed by Shina speaking communities all across the Shina speaking areas – mostly inhabiting northern Pakistan and part of the Indian held Kashmir- to popularize and universalize a homogenized approach to a unified code aimed at sustaining and preserving this language which is sadly on the wane.
To give a recent example, Shakil Ahmad Shakil carried out a research work culminating in his products like ‘dade shilokeh’ (grandmas’s tales) and Shina Grammar, Aziz-ur-Rehman Malangi’s Shina Diwan and to top them all is Haji Shah Mirza’s translation of the Holy Qura’an into Shina which is greatly contributive to the existing literature in Shina. There is no gainsaying that viewed in terms of it originality of form, diction and etymology, Shin…